Last week it was my privilege to attend the Prayer Book Society USA's two and a half day 2018 Conference in historic Savannah Georgia. I was there last year as well, and while this year's attendance was smaller than last year's, I think the overall quality of the papers presented was better than those I heard in 2017.
We met at St. John's Episcopal Church in Savannah whose keeping and teaching of the Faith allows me to use the word, "church" in the same breath as the word "Episcopal", something I have not been able to do of late. St. John's has stuck to the 1928 American Prayer Book and the 1940 Episcopalian Hymnal for use in worship, and this makes them an odd duck in the Episcopal organization. Their average Sunday attendance of 400 souls in 2016 is very healthy by Episcopal standards, but it is down from over 500 in 2006.
I took some notes which I will share with you over the next few weeks.
The theme for the 2018 Conference was, "The Prayer Book: Doctrine Liturgy and Life"
Beginning on Wednesday afternoon, the Presidential Address,
Everything changed in 1970 after an entirely new Roman Catholic lectionary, the OLM, was introduced. The Common Lectionary (CL) began being adopted by Protestant churches and found its way into the Episcopal Book of Common Prayer in 1979. In 1992 the Revised Common Lectionary (RCL) was published and is used by many denominations and Episcopal churches today..
The aim of the CL and the RCL was to increase the amount of scripture read by creating a three year cycle instead of the earlier lectionaries' one year cycle. What we lost was continuity and repetition as well as significant chunks of teaching (as documented many times on this lowly blog). The RCL also disconnects the Old Testament reading and the Epistle from the Gospel selection leading to a lack of cohesiveness and teachable points. One example of the loss of chunks of scripture is the loss of much of Romans Chapters 1, 2, and 3 which contain teachings on condemnation without which there is little need for the instructions on justification by faith to be found in subsequent chapters. "The RCL presents a buffet service of the Bible, the quantity is larger but the quality is not so good."
In summary, the RCL is like a multipurpose kitchen gadget that tries to do a lot of things well but does not do any of them well enough.
This was followed by,
The idea that we do not need to have the requirement for repentance recited on a daily or weekly basis in our Prayer Book puts us in the same position as the secularists, "They are not led by God to think they might be wrong".
Following Evening Prayer (1928) there was a reception at the adjacent Green Meldrim House which was General William Tecumseh Sherman's headquarters when the Federal army occupied Savannah during the Civil War .
Following that, those who didn't get their fill at the reception retreated to their favorite restaurant for dinner.
Thus endeth the first day.
We met at St. John's Episcopal Church in Savannah whose keeping and teaching of the Faith allows me to use the word, "church" in the same breath as the word "Episcopal", something I have not been able to do of late. St. John's has stuck to the 1928 American Prayer Book and the 1940 Episcopalian Hymnal for use in worship, and this makes them an odd duck in the Episcopal organization. Their average Sunday attendance of 400 souls in 2016 is very healthy by Episcopal standards, but it is down from over 500 in 2006.
I took some notes which I will share with you over the next few weeks.
The theme for the 2018 Conference was, "The Prayer Book: Doctrine Liturgy and Life"
Beginning on Wednesday afternoon, the Presidential Address,
“The Ancient Catholic Lectionaryat the heart of a Reformed Liturgy”.was delivered by the Revd. Fr. Gavin Dunbar, President of the Prayer Book Society. He spoke about the ancient origins of lectionaries. Continuous reading of the Gospel may have been the custom with the exception of Easter when a "proper" lesson fitting the season would be selected. In post-Nicene Rome, the Bishop selected the scripture. By the end of the 6th century, non-continuous reading was becoming common with scriptures befitting each liturgical season. By the 8th century, readings, chants, and prayers were formalized as seen in the Romano-Frankish lectionary. The Papal court was one exception.
Everything changed in 1970 after an entirely new Roman Catholic lectionary, the OLM, was introduced. The Common Lectionary (CL) began being adopted by Protestant churches and found its way into the Episcopal Book of Common Prayer in 1979. In 1992 the Revised Common Lectionary (RCL) was published and is used by many denominations and Episcopal churches today..
The aim of the CL and the RCL was to increase the amount of scripture read by creating a three year cycle instead of the earlier lectionaries' one year cycle. What we lost was continuity and repetition as well as significant chunks of teaching (as documented many times on this lowly blog). The RCL also disconnects the Old Testament reading and the Epistle from the Gospel selection leading to a lack of cohesiveness and teachable points. One example of the loss of chunks of scripture is the loss of much of Romans Chapters 1, 2, and 3 which contain teachings on condemnation without which there is little need for the instructions on justification by faith to be found in subsequent chapters. "The RCL presents a buffet service of the Bible, the quantity is larger but the quality is not so good."
In summary, the RCL is like a multipurpose kitchen gadget that tries to do a lot of things well but does not do any of them well enough.
This was followed by,
"Justification in Anglicanism and the Prayer Book"delivered by the Rt. Revd. C. Fitzsimons Allison, Retired Bishop of South Carolina. Fitz described the definition of and the importance of repentance. Repentance is "a renewal of love" (Ashley Null) and is a change of heart not a change of mind. We cannot understand justification without repentance and vice versa. Older Prayer Books contained a stronger message of the need for repentance. When this language is removed or watered down as we see in the 1979 Episcopal Book of Common Prayer, we can easily fall under the spell of the Pelagian heresy. To quote Fitz, "Pelagianism is the banana peel on the cliff of Unitarianism."
The idea that we do not need to have the requirement for repentance recited on a daily or weekly basis in our Prayer Book puts us in the same position as the secularists, "They are not led by God to think they might be wrong".
Following Evening Prayer (1928) there was a reception at the adjacent Green Meldrim House which was General William Tecumseh Sherman's headquarters when the Federal army occupied Savannah during the Civil War .
Following that, those who didn't get their fill at the reception retreated to their favorite restaurant for dinner.
Thus endeth the first day.